The answer, as it turned out, was two.
It seems so simple now. Go to Google. Search. Bingo. It wasn't like
that then. You had to dig, explore, call, interview, be patient. And then write. I'm fine with you being on my lawn, so that's
not what this is. But there was something about the quest, the connecting the dots, the archives, the clips, the lights going
off in your head along the way rather than seeing what shows up after you hit "Enter."
One of the baseball players killed in action was Harry O'Neill,
who caught one game for the Philadelphia Athletics in 1939. He wasn't on the initial lists I found, but eventually I
came across information about him (including, much later, in the 2008 book, When Baseball Went to War). He was raised
in Philadelphia and played football, basketball and baseball at Gettysburg College. After graduating, he signed with the Athletics,
but soon entered the Marines and was a first lieutenant in the Pacific fighting. He was killed on Iwo Jima on March 6, 1945.
The other was outfielder Elmer Gedeon, who played
five games with the Washington Senators, also in 1939. The Official Baseball Yearbook of '45 told me that Gedeon had
15 at-bats, three singles and a .200 average. He was a big guy -- 6-foot-4 and 196 pounds -- from Cleveland. He died,
the book said, in France, on April 15, 1944.
That was his 27th birthday.
That's what I started
set out to find out what I could about Gedeon. Was he unique? In many ways, because he was a gifted all-around athlete,
he was. In another very crucial way, as an American who served in World War II, he wasn't.
So consider Elmer
John Gedeon a symbol.
The story of his first game was in the Oregonian's microfilm:
"WASHINGTON, Sept. 18 (AP) - Dutch Leonard won his 19th game of the season Monday when his
Washington team defeated the Detroit Tigers 4 to 2."
was spelled "Gedgeon" in the box score below. But he was there, playing right field. One at-bat, no
hits, one putout, no assists.
The lead picture in the sports section that day was of tennis
star Don Budge in London, carrying a book under his arm. The title: "Hitler's Mein Kampf." The caption noted
that Budge "is studying Hitler," whose German troops had invaded Poland on Sept. 1. Britain and France
declared war on Sept. 3. World War II was two weeks old. Fifteen months before the U.S. entered the war, Elmer Gedeon had
played his first major-league game.
On Sept. 20, Gedeon's position was "m" --
or what the boxes then labeled center field. He went 3 for 4 in a 10-9 victory over Cleveland. Over the next three days,
as Joe Louis was winning a title fight with an 11th-round knockout of Bob Pastor and congressmen were pictured with
stacks of "peace mail" on the back page of the sports section ("Lest we forget, let's stay out!")
and Hitler was shown shaking hands in Danzig, Gedeon went hitless his next three games.
from the box scores for good.
The 1941 American League Red Book carried biographies of
the Washington rookies, including one Elmer Gedeon, "recalled from Charlotte. Gedeon, famous as a
track man at the University of Michigan, is very fast and shows signs of being a big-leaguer in another year."
But there was no evidence of Gedeon ever playing another game, so I set out to find
out more about him.
The Cleveland phone directory listed 97 Gedeons. There was
one Elmer, on Outlook Drive. A son, perhaps?
No, said the woman who answered:
Her late husband was named Elmer, but he wasn't the one who attended Michigan and played for the Senators.
Thinking of his middle name, I tried the John Gedeons. Mrs. John F. Gedeon sympathized
and told me that the name was so common in her area because immigrants from Metzenzeifen, in the Sudetenland, were prone
to settle in Cleveland.
And Gedeon was a common last name in their native
land, she said.
The 10th listing, a "C Gedeon," turned out to be for Charlotte Gedeon. Yes,
she said, she was Elmer's third cousin.
"He carried my grandmother's casket," she said.
"Oh, he was a handsome fellow."
She told me to call Robert Gedeon, Elmer's first
cousin, and gave me the number for one of the nine Robert Gedeons in the phone book. Robert G. "Bob" Gedeon was
happy to talk about Elmer.
"We were only a year apart," Bob said, "so we were very close."
They used to play in Cleveland's Brookside Park. "One time we were ice skating and I
went through the ice, up to my neck," Bob said. "Elmer slid across the ice on his belly and pulled me
He told of Elmer's athletic heroics at West High, then at Michigan in football, track
and baseball. Football, too? You bet, said Bob, a retired foundry worker.
about Elmer surviving a 1942 crash during training in North Carolina. Two of the six crewmen were killed.
Elmer won the Soldiers Medal, Bob said, for pulling a crewman out of the burning plane. Rarrat's
back and both legs were broken. Gedeon was the navigator on the training flight. Clippings from the Cleveland Plain
Dealer later confirmed that Gedeon suffered burns and required skin graft surgery, and also suffered three broken
"The last time I saw him," Bob said, "he told me, 'I had my accident.
It's going to be good flying from now on.' He said he had used up his bad luck. That didn't turn out to be true."
Bob said Elmer's widow, Laura, moved to Florida. As far as he knew, Bob said, she no
longer was alive. Bob said that when Elmer was inducted into the Michigan Hall of Honor in 1983, Bob received Elmer's
plaque because he was the closest relative who could be located.
look at the Michigan press guide confirmed that Elmer had lettered in football from 1936-38, playing with renowned
backs Tom Harmon and Forest Evashevski. The school's sports information department added some more details. (They came
from a young student intern who, I could tell, had no idea about Gedeon until he did the research for me, but he was
wide-eyed and impressed.) Gedeon also won two letters in baseball and track, hitting .320 for the baseball team
and holding American indoor records inthe 70- and 75-yard high hurdles. He was the conference's high- and low-hurdles
champion, both outdoors and indoors, in 1938 and '39.
Evashevski, the retired University
of Iowa coach and athletic director, was living in Petoskey, Mich., when I contacted him. "Oh, "Ged' was a
super guy," Evashevski said on the
phone. "He was a very, very humble person for a guy who had all his talent."
said they both belonged to the Phi Delta Gamma fraternity. "He recruited me," Evashevski said. "I asked
him what kind of guys they had. He said, "Well, all of them are about like me.' I joined. But the thing was, there
couldn't be too many like him."
Evashevski said Gedeon was a good, not great, football
end, but was remarkable in the spring sports. "He'd win the hurdles, then change uniforms and play for the baseball
team," Evashevski said.
Dona Basel, a librarian at the Plain Dealer, FAXed me nine pages of copies
of its Gedeon clippings. One 1938 headline jumped out: "He's
Too Good For His Own Good."
In June 1939, a week before commencement, Gedeon signed with the Senators, choosing baseball over
a possible berth on the 1940 Olympic track team. (The '40 Games, scheduled for Finland, later were canceled.) He joined
the Senators when they came to Cleveland in mid-June, prompting this headline in the Cleveland Press: "Campus
to Majors in 24 Hours - Saga of Gedeon." There was speculation that he would step in at first base for the
released veteran, Jimmy Wasdell.
Apparently unware that the Olympic track team would have
been determined in Trials, Gedeon told Howard Preston of the Cleveland News: "I'm not sure that I would have
been chosen for the Olympic team next summer but I heard I was being considered. Then I was chosen for the Big Ten all-star
(baseball) team which leaves tomorrow for a tour of the Pacific Coast
– and the itinerary includes Hollywood and the San Francisco Fair. If I signed a contract, I’d forfeit both trips.
So I thought it over and finally decided I’d better do something practical. Hollywood will be there a long time and,
well, there will be other fairs. So I signed a contract.”
In another story in the Cleveland Press, he said: “I don’t know
what’s in store for me. If I make the grade, I’ll probably be kept.”
Before he played game,
the Senators sent him down to Orlando of the Florida State League, where he was converted to the outfield. Returning to Washington,
he got in those five games at the end of the ‘39 season. He wasn’t ready for the majors, but it seemed a matter
of time. He was with Charlotte in the Piedmont League in 1940 and was recalled at the end of the year, but didn’t get
in any Senators’ games. He went back to Michigan to coach the freshman football team in the fall of ‘40, was five
hours short of a master’s degree, and was preparing for another shot with the Senators when he was drafted in March
He got in those five games that season. He wasn't ready for the majors, but it seemed
a matter of time. He spent the next season with Charlotte in the minors, went back to Michigan to coach the freshman
football team in the fall of 1940 and was preparing for another shot with the Senators when he was drafted in March '41.
My friend Neal Rubin of the Detroit News did a column on Gedeon in 2003, citing my original research and quoting from my interview with
Bob Gedeon, and then adding some new information. He located an April ‘41 Phi Gamma Delta newsletter in which Gedeon
told his fraternity brothers: “As you probably know by this time, Old Ged has been drafted.” He thought it was
funny that he had been assigned to the cavalry, adding, “the only horse I ever saw in my life was the one the milkman
He spent some time in the cavalry
forces, then transferred to the Air Corps.
After his plane crashed during training in August 1942, when he was awarded the Soldiers Medal in Tampa, the Cleveland
Press headline said: "Gedeon Honored With Huge Parade."
An excerpt from the citation: “After extricating himself, Lieut. Gedeon, regardless
of the fact that he had suffered broken ribs and severe burns, re-entered the burning wreckage and removed Corp. John R. Rarrat,
fellow crew member, who had been rendered helpless in the crash. Corp. Rarrat would have burned to death had it not been for
the unselfish action of Lieut. Gedeon.”
By April 1944, he was based
in England and was a B-26 Marauder pilot, the head of a crew of seven. The Allied invasion of the European mainland was six
weeks away. Gedeon wrote to his wife on April 19, then left on a mission the next day. They headed to German
construction works in Bois d'Esquerdes, France. The plane was hit by German fire, burst into flames and went into a nosedive.
Only co-pilot James Taafe made it out and parachuted to the ground. Gedeon was buried at St. Pol. Later, his remains were
brought to Arlington National Cemetery.
The Baseball Encyclopedia is five days off on his
date of Gedeon's death. Below that, all you see is that Elmer Gedeon appeared in five big-league games.
He went 3-for-15 at the plate. That doesn't do him justice -- both as a man and as a symbol.